IN REVIEW: Alexisonfire - "Otherness"
Reunions can be tricky things to navigate, especially when they result in new music. Expectations become deeply engrained in fans' minds when the prospect of a grand recorded return is floated; it's only natural that, when you think of any artist you respect or admire, you remember their best work first. The risk of sullying a legacy comes into play if what you're returning with doesn't meet those expectations, even if they're unfair; that said, to expect any band to maintain the same youthful energy and creative intensity that they had during their peak is to practice a losing game in most cases, and I would argue that the responsibility is just as great for the listener as it is the artist in these situations. For example, if you're prepared to dismiss the first full-length Alexisonfire album in 13 years because it doesn't go as hard as Watch Out! or Crisis , you're entitled to your opinion but you're not doing yourself any favours as a fan; he...