Year in Rock 2011: Top 20 Albums

-
When pondering this year's best albums, I was faced with a fairly difficult decision, in which I basically had to rethink my entire outlook on what makes a good album?  When it came down to crunch time (read: 20 minutes ago), I had to stop flip-flopping on the top two and choose one that would, by merit of its position on the list, be hailed as "the better album".

My conclusion (for the purposes of this list, anyway) is that a masterwork in craft, skill and substance from beginning to end should trump a collection of great songs.  I'm not saying writing a song is easy by any stretch, but writing a series of songs and building them into a sum that transcends its parts is much more difficult.  In the end, I like the top two equally, but for different reasons.  #2 is hands down the year's better collection of songs.  But my pick for top spot is a shining example of the fading art that is creating a true album.  Yes, it's a bloated, confusing mess at times.  And no, its songs don't quite stack up side-by-side with #2.  But, when played front to back, it delivers a bigger rush; it feels important, like an album destined to be revered in 15 years the way OK Computer is now.  And there can only be one explanation as to why: it is.

Willie's Top 20 Albums of 2011
(To refresh your memory as to what made these so good, click on them to scoot to its nomination write-up).

20. STEPHEN MALKMUS & THE JICKS: Mirror Traffic
19. CHEVELLE: Hats Off to the Bull
18. MARIACHI EL BRONX: Mariachi el Bronx II
17. PUSCIFER: Conditions of My Parole
16. THE HORRIBLE CROWES: Elsie
15. KASABIAN: Velociraptor!
14. ...AND YOU WILL KNOW US BY THE TRAIL OF DEAD: Tao of the Dead
13. HEY ROSETTA!: Seeds
12. THE BLACK KEYS: El Camino
11. RED FANG: Murder the Mountains
10. DROPKICK MURPHYS: Going Out in Style
9. THRICE: Major/Minor
8. TOM WAITS: Bad As Me
7. MANCHESTER ORCHESTRA: Simple Math
6. THE DECEMBERISTS: The King is Dead
5. MACHINE HEAD: Unto the Locust
4. ARCTIC MONKEYS: Suck It and See
3. MASTODON: The Hunter
2. FOO FIGHTERS: Wasting Light
1. FUCKED UP: David Comes to Life

Again, thanks for checking out the blog over the past couple of months and sharing this weird obsession I call rock with me.  There's lots coming in the new year, so don't be a stranger, K?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

IN REVIEW: Hey Rosetta! - "Second Sight"

-
Image
There's a telling lyrical passage that stuck out to me upon listening to Newfoundland-based indie stalwarts Hey Rosetta's third full-length LP. During the uplifting, depression-battling anthem Cathedral Bells , singer Tim Baker exclaims, "the road is lit and I'm going home". It comes near the tail end of the album's most thrilling section of songs, during which the seven-piece (plus additional hands on deck for extra orchestration) take a formidable musical journey through several genres and moods. After exploring the arena-sized farthest reaches of Coldplay, the worldly rhythms of Vampire Weekend and the zealous, choral flourishes of Arcade Fire among others, it's the comfort of home that drives the group down the album's (pun intended, I suppose) home stretch. Long before we get to that point, however, we're treated to some of the band's most interesting material to date. The album starts with current single Soft Offering (for the Oft Suff...
Read more

Trent Reznor, You Glorious Scheming Bastard.

-
Image
As it turns out, something I said on this blog earlier this year had a little more resonance than I anticipated. From my January 15th article " What Are The Chances? ", where I gave a percentage chance for certain artists releasing a new album in 2013: 1% NINE INCH NAILS We know that Trent Reznor is gearing up to release How To Destroy Angels' debut. We also know that there's an Interscope-released Nine Inch Nails greatest hits collection being targeted for 2014, for which Reznor promises two new Nine Inch Nails songs. But, we also know Reznor likes to fuck with his fans and absolutely loved fucking with Interscope. What better way to do that than to bring out a brand new Nine Inch Nails record? What better way indeed? Surprise: A new #NIN album is finished, coming later this year on @ columbiarecords : tmblr.co/ZW-7vsm2kw_u #NIN2013 — Nine Inch Nails (@nineinchnails) May 28, 2013 Bravo, Mr. Reznor. I love it when a plan comes together. More on...
Read more