Year in Rock 2011: Top 20 Albums
When pondering this year's best albums, I was faced with a fairly difficult decision, in which I basically had to rethink my entire outlook on what makes a good album? When it came down to crunch time (read: 20 minutes ago), I had to stop flip-flopping on the top two and choose one that would, by merit of its position on the list, be hailed as "the better album". My conclusion (for the purposes of this list, anyway) is that a masterwork in craft, skill and substance from beginning to end should trump a collection of great songs. I'm not saying writing a song is easy by any stretch, but writing a series of songs and building them into a sum that transcends its parts is much more difficult. In the end, I like the top two equally, but for different reasons. #2 is hands down the year's better collection of songs. But my pick for top spot is a shining example of the fading art that is creating a true album. Yes, it's a bloated, confusing mess at times....