Year in Rock 2011 Nominee: The Decemberists

THE DECEMBERISTS
Down By the Water

From: The King is Dead
Released: January 18

Renowned for intricate albums chock full of murder ballads and high concepts, the Decemberists released what vocalist Colin Meloy referred to as "an exercise in restraint" in 2011.  The King is Dead doesn't have an overarching storyline, song suites, or even a particularly high body count.  What it lacks in familiar Decemberists fare, however, it makes up for in heartfelt, well-written songs.  Musically, most of the album is less cabaret and more Americana compared to earlier efforts, and it really does work.  Plus, the lack of concept gives the songs a chance to stand on their own merit.  Sure, it's no doubt fun to create a cast of characters and give them a songbook, but by throwing out the box that concept albums lock a writer into, the Decemberists have given their most cohesive, most concise and (most importantly) most enjoyable set of songs yet. 

Choosing one to showcase proved difficult, as there are a handful of very strong tracks present on The King is Dead.  I went with Down By the Water because it best splits the difference between the album's softer and harder moments.  Plus, it doesn't hurt to count R.E.M.'s Peter Buck as a friend willing to lay down a guitar line that calls to mind Buck's (former) day job.


Of course, when your band is known for storytelling and high concepts, you sometimes can't help but tell stories and dream up high concepts.  That's why Meloy announced a three-year Decemberists hiatus earlier this year, a break imposed on the band so Meloy can focus on other projects.  Among those projects?  An illustrated book series for young adults, a musical he plans on writing, and perhaps one or more solo endeavours, as well as spending more time with his autistic son.  So much for restraint, I guess.